|
|
||||||||
RESEARCH AND PRACTICE |
Robert S. Kahn is with the Division of General and Community Pediatrics, Childrens Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, Ohio. Barry Zuckerman, Howard Bauchner, and Paul H. Wise are with the Department of Pediatrics, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, Mass. Charles J. Homer is with the Division of General Pediatrics, Childrens Hospital, Boston, Mass.
Correspondence: Requests for reprints should be sent to Robert S. Kahn, MD, MPH, Division of General and Community Pediatrics, Childrens Hospital Medical Center TCHRF 6549, 3333 Burnet Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45229-3039 (e-mail: robert.kahn{at}chmcc.org).
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objectives. This study examined the persistence and comorbidity of womens physical and mental health conditions after pregnancy and the association of these conditions with child outcomes.
Methods. A national cohort of women who recently gave birth were surveyed in 1988 and again in 1991. We examined longitudinal data on maternal poor physical health, depressive symptoms, and smoking, and maternal report of child outcomes (at age
3 years).
Results. Womens poor physical health and smoking had strong, graded associations with childrens physical health and behavior problems, whereas womens depressive symptoms were associated with childrens delayed language and behavior problems.
Conclusions. Substantial persistence and comorbidity of womens health conditions exist after pregnancy with adverse effects on early child outcomes. Child health professionals should support services and policies that promote womens health outside the context of pregnancy.
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Significant gaps exist in research linking womens health after pregnancy and early child outcomes. First, most studies have sought to isolate the effects of single maternal risk factors, such as smoking.9,10 There has been little effort to assess more comprehensively the interrelated conditions women experience after delivery and the scope of their influence on child outcomes. For example, despite the well-documented association between adult smoking and depression,11 little is known about their joint effect on child health. Furthermore, most studies have relied on cross-sectional assessments of the maternal and child health relationship. More longitudinal approaches are needed to clarify the continuity or persistence of conditions over time and to provide accurate estimates of effects.12 For example, longitudinal models have better delineated the effect of prolonged exposure to poverty on both birth outcomes and child development.13,14 The disadvantage of a focus on isolated maternal risk factors, assessed at a single point in time, is evident in the multiple distinct and unrelated calls for action on the part of child health professionals.1520 Little coherent support among pediatricians has been generated for more comprehensive and continuous health care for women after they deliver.2124
The goal of this study was to offer a broader perspective on the scope and persistence of the maternal and child health relationship after pregnancy as an empirical first step in reconsidering current health programs and policies for women and their children. Specifically, we used a longitudinal cohort to examine maternal poor physical health, depressive symptoms, and smoking at 2 points in time after delivery and their association with child health and development at age 3 years. We also examined social and economic factors that may frame the distribution of maternal conditions.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Child Outcomes
Child outcomes were from the 1991 Longitudinal Follow-Up survey and reflect physical health, language, and behavior outcomes. Child physical health outcomes, as reported by the mother, included the childs general health status (dichotomized as excellent/very good/good vs fair/poor), having ever been hospitalized (not including at birth), and the mother having ever been told by a health care provider that the child had asthma. Language outcomes included maternal report (yes/no) as to whether the child had ever counted 3 objects correctly, said the names of at least 4 colors, and counted out loud to 10. Child behavior was assessed with 3 questions: whether the child was difficult to manage most of the time (vs easy to manage/sometimes difficult), whether the child had some or great difficulty playing with other children (vs got along well all or most of the time), and whether the child had frequent tantrums (vs never/occasional tantrums).
Womens Health
Womens health was characterized by self-reported physical health status, depressive symptoms, and smoking. Based on data from both the 1988 and the 1991 surveys, the health states were categorized as present both times, present 1 time, or absent.27 From prior work on womens physical health after delivery,28 physical health was characterized as poor in 1988 if a mother reported being rehospitalized or having had 3 or more visits to a doctor in the interval since delivery (17 ± 5 months) and as poor in 1991 if a mother reported her general health to be fair or poor (vs excellent/very good/good) at the time of the second survey. Depressive symptoms were ascertained with the 20question Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale administered in both the 1988 and the 1991 surveys. A score of 16 or greater is considered positive in screening for depression.29 Maternal smoking was assessed with a single question (yes/no) both in 1988 and in 1991. Prior studies have shown the correlation between self-reported maternal smoking and infant urine cotinine level to be good.30
Sociodemographic and Other Covariates
In the 1988 survey, mothers were asked to report on their total family income in the 12 months before delivery. To adjust for family size, a ratio of income to poverty line income to poverty line was created based on the 1988 federal poverty thresholds. For example, an income of $6000 for a family of 4 was divided by the federal threshold of $12 092 to yield a ratio of 0.5. The ratio was then categorized into quintiles (< 0.9, 0.91.9, 2.03.3, 3.44.8, > 4.8). Other covariates included the mothers age (< 20 years, 2029 years, 30 years and older), highest attained education (< high school, high school or general equivalency diploma,
some college), marital status (married, separated/divorced, single), race/ethnicity (White non-Hispanic, Black non-Hispanic, Hispanic), birthweight (< 1500 g, 15002499 g,
2500 g), and the childs age at the time of the 1991 survey. Additional variables used to adjust for the infants health status at birth included the presence of a major birth defect (spina bifida, heart condition, cerebral palsy, hydrocephalus, sickle cell anemia, or other genetic disorder), history of hospital transfer at birth, and rehospitalization in the first month after discharge.
Analysis
Bivariate relationships between maternal health and child outcomes were assessed with
2 analyses. Logistic regression was used for multivariate analyses. Variables for the 3 maternal health conditions were entered together into the models. This ensured, for example, that the association of child outcomes with maternal physical health was estimated independently of any comorbid depressive symptoms. Potential interactions between comorbid maternal conditions were explored. All multivariate models were adjusted for maternal age, income, education, marital status, and race/ethnicity and for child birthweight and age. Finally, to address the potential for reverse causation (i.e., that childrens poor health at birth might be the primary determinant of maternal conditions in the next 3 years), a final set of regressions reexamined these relationships in a restricted sample of infants most likely to be healthy at birth (
2500 g, no history of major birth conditions, no hospital transfer after delivery, and no rehospitalization in the first month after discharge). All analyses were weighted to account for the complex survey design and for nonresponse; weights were provided by the National Center for Health Statistics. Analyses were conducted with SUDAAN, Version 7.5.3 (Research Triangle Institute, Research Triangle Park, NC).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The prevalence of each health condition is shown in Table 1
. Among the women, depressive symptoms were the most commonly reported condition and smoking was the most likely to be reported both times. Approximately 60% of the women reported at least 1 of these conditions. Comorbidity was common, with 24% of the women ever reporting 2 or more conditions. For example, more than 40% of the women with persistent smoking and more than 50% of the women with persistent poor physical health also reported depressive symptoms in at least 1 time period. Twenty-two percent of the mothers reported that their child had 1 or more poor physical health outcomes, 51% reported that their child had not reached 1 or more of the language milestones, and 25% noted that their child had 1 or more of the behavior problems.
|
|
|
|
To address the potential for reverse causation (i.e., that poor child health at birth primarily determined maternal health in the subsequent 3 years), the analyses were rerun but restricted to infants most likely to be healthy at birth (i.e., normal birthweight, no major birth conditions, no hospital transfer at birth, and no rehospitalization in the first month after discharge). There was no change in the associations between maternal health conditions and child health outcomes.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Our findings with a national cohort confirm and extend previous studies drawn from a variety of clinical populations.28,32,33 Crosssectional surveys of women bringing their children for pediatric care have found that 15% to 40% report depressive symptoms and that 9% to 40% smoke, depending on the demographic characteristics of the clinic sample.32,33 The substantial comorbidity seen in this study is similar to that found in a prevalence study of 8 health conditions in women with children younger than 18 months.33 Much less work has been done on the persistence of these maternal conditions. Haas and McCormick28 investigated poor physical health among women who had delivered low-birthweight infants. They found that 16.9% of the women reported fair or poor health and that almost 30% were hospitalized in the 5 years after delivery. The persistence of depressive symptoms found in our nationally representative sample is similar to that of another recent large study of mothers with young children.34
The strong gradient between income before delivery and comorbidity and persistence of negative maternal health conditions in the years following delivery is striking, especially in the context of the prevalence of low income among childbearing women.35 Acknowledging the social and structural forces that shape the distribution of these conditions is critical for understanding the upstream causes of health disparities and for developing effective interventions.36 Interventions for maternal smoking that implicitly emphasize the role of individual volition may fail owing to lack of recognition of the forces structuring womens options (e.g., access to nicotine patches).37 Similar failures may result from inability to appreciate the structural barriers faced by women with depression (e.g., access to affordable mental health services).
Although the specific pattern of maternal and child health associations we found is supported by a constellation of prior studies, the scope and persistence of these relationships have not been previously reported. Maternal smoking has been linked to childhood asthma, hospitalization, and behavior problems,9,10 and maternal depression is known to be associated with child language development34 and behavior problems,20 thus offering some support for the validity of our conceptual framework and outcome measures. That the relationships span multiple maternal conditions and cut across various domains of child health and development suggests that a common interest in ensuring womens comprehensive health may emerge from diverse clinical disciplines. Our findings also imply that interest in more narrowly framed conditions, such as postpartum depression, should take a more longitudinal perspective and should assess the additional burden imposed by other co-occurring maternal morbidities. Taken together, this broad intergenerational effect on health in the first years after delivery may help to inform recent findings on the capability of early parental socioeconomic status and well-being to alter childrens health trajectories over the life course.37,38
With respect to interventions, our findings suggest that highly targeted initiatives to address maternal health problems may not be adequate to alter outcomes for many women and children. Findings on maternal depression, smoking, folic acid levels, and domestic violence, among others, have led to a series of calls for pediatric action. Given the persistence and comorbidity of these problems, however, a more integrated strategy to link women to adult clinicians or social agencies may be needed.
Such a strategy might involve use of child-oriented settings as gateways to care for women. These settings might include, for example, pediatric clinics and Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children clinics, as well as Early Intervention and Head Start programs. In the health care setting, this approach would complement the work of family practice in ensuring comprehensive health care for families.39 These gateways or links could be built on the strengths of specific sites, such as the collocation of adult and pediatric clinicians or the integrated information systems of health maintenance organizations. Recent state efforts to expand Medicaid and State Childrens Health Insurance Program eligibility for parents may reflect an important step toward reducing financial barriers to such a strategy.3,40,41 Continuous health care also should address womens health well before any pregnancy; substantial work remains to be done in this regard.
Several considerations should frame the interpretation of these findings. Health information on the cohort was limited to 2 time points separated by approximately 18 months. Conditions present at both times actually may have been recurrent rather than persistent. The persistence or recurrence of these conditions and their effect on child health need to be more fully delineated. However, few longitudinal data sets include multiple measures of womens health and child outcomes.42 Similarly, we know of no longitudinal data sets with which to address the role of paternal health. Women responded to questions on their own behalf and on behalf of their children, raising the possibility that women in poor physical or mental health may have simply perceived their children to be in worse health. That women with persistent depressive symptoms were not more likely to report their children to have poor physical health, however, makes this possibility somewhat less likely. Future research should include the use of nonparental informants and validated assessment tools.
The temporal sequence in which the variables were measured is a relative strength of the analysis, but reverse causation cannot be ruled out. Poor health status at birth may have led to both maternal depression and adverse child outcomes at age 3 years. However, when analyses were restricted to normalbirthweight infants without major birth conditions or early rehospitalization, the findings were unchanged. Nevertheless, complex relationships likely operate in which the poor health of the mother and the child become reinforcing. Taken together, the consistency, strength, and graded nature of the associations found, along with their temporal sequence and biological plausibility, make it unlikely that these limitations substantially undermine the results.
This study focused on the relevance of womens health to childrens outcomes. Clearly, these same health conditions adversely affect womens capacity in roles other than parenting. The degree to which adults poor physical and mental health undermine successful employment and social relationships, as well as long-term health trajectories, suggests that demands for improved health services for women need not be premised solely on their benefits for child outcomes. Rather, these findings should serve to encourage the child health community to join womens health advocates in promoting womens access to comprehensive and continuous health services.
Our data suggest that inequalities in the health of women may be a primary contributor to health disparities in young children and that these intergenerational effects on health are not confined to pregnancy. Although the child health community has long supported the provision of health services to women while they are pregnant, these findings imply the need to expand that commitment beyond the prenatal period. Such a commitment might begin with efforts to configure practical health service, health insurance, and public health initiatives that ensure optimal outcomes for both women and their children.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Human Participant Protection
No protocol approval was needed for this study.
| Footnotes |
|---|
Accepted for publication September 28, 2001.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2. Katz ME, Holmes MD, Power KL, Wise PH. Mortality rates among 15- to 44-year-old women in Boston: looking beyond reproductive status. Am J Public Health. 1995;85:11351138.
3. Guyer J, Broaddus M, Dude A. Millions of Mothers Lack Health Insurance Coverage. Washington, DC: Center on Budget and Policy Priorities; 2001:110.
4. Kempe A, Wise PH, Barkan SE, et al. Clinical determinants of the racial disparity in very low birth weight. N Engl J Med. 1992;327:969973.[Abstract]
5. Laurence KM, James N, Miller M, Tennant G, Campbell H. Double blind randomized control trial of folate treatment before conception to prevent recurrence of neural-tube defects. BMJ. 1981;282:15091511.
6. Leuzzi RA, Scoles KS. Preconception counseling for the primary care physician. Med Clin North Am. 1996;80:337374.[Medline]
7. Jack BW, Culpepper L, Babcock J, Kogan MD, Weismiller D. Addressing preconception risks identified at the time of a negative pregnancy test: a randomized trial. J Fam Pract. 1998;47:3338.[Medline]
8. ACOG technical bulletin: preconceptional care. No. 205May 1995. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 1995;50:201207.[Medline]
9. DiFranza JR, Lew RA. Morbidity and mortality in children associated with the use of tobacco products by other people. Pediatrics. 1996;97:560568.
10. Weitzman M, Gortmaker S, Sobol A. Maternal smoking and behavior problems of children. Pediatrics. 1992;90:342349.
11. Borrelli B, Bock B, King T, Pinto B, Marcus BH. The impact of depression on smoking cessation in women. Am J Prev Med. 1996;12:378387.[Medline]
12. Wolfe B, Haveman R, Ginther D, An CB. The "window problem" in studies of childrens attainments: a methodological exploration. J Am Stat Assoc. 1996;91:970982.
13. Starfield B, Shapiro S, Weiss J, et al. Race, family income, and low birthweight. Am J Epidemiol. 1991;134:11671174.
14. Duncan GJ, Brooks-Gunn J, Klebanov PK. Economic deprivation and early childhood development. Child Dev. 1994;65:296318.[Medline]
15. Wall MA, Severson HH, Andrews JA, Lichtenstein G, Zoref L. Pediatric office-based smoking intervention: impact on maternal smoking and relapse. Pediatrics. 1995;96:622628.
16. Environmental tobacco smoke: a hazard to children. American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Environmental Health. Pediatrics. 1997;99:639642.
17. Duffy SJ, McGrath ME, Becker BM, Linakis JG. Mothers with histories of domestic violence in a pediatric emergency department. Pediatrics. 1999;103:10071013.
18. The role of the pediatrician in recognizing and intervening on behalf of abused women. American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Child Abuse and Neglect. Pediatrics. 1998;101:10911092.
19. Heneghan AM, Silver EJ, Bauman LJ, Westbrook LE, Stein RE. Depressive symptoms in inner-city mothers of young children: who is at risk? Pediatrics. 1998;102:13941400.
20. Zuckerman BS, Beardslee WR. Maternal depression: a concern for pediatricians. Pediatrics. 1987;79:110117.
21. Commonwealth Fund. The Commonwealth Fund Survey of Womens Health. New York, NY: Commonwealth Fund; 1993.
22. Clancy C, Massion C. American womens health care: a patchwork quilt with gaps. JAMA. 1992;268:19181920.[Medline]
23. Bartels PL, Boroniec P. BadgerCare: a case study of the elusive new federalism. Health Aff (Millwood). 1998;17:165169.[Abstract]
24. Thorpe K, Florence C. Covering Uninsured Children and Their Parents: Estimated Costs and Number of Newly Insured. New York, NY: Commonwealth Fund; 1998.
25. Sanderson M, Placek PJ, Keppel KG. The 1988 National Maternal and Infant Health Survey: design, content, and data availability. Birth. 1991;18:2632.[Medline]
26. Kogan MD, Pappas G, Yu SM, Kotelchuck M. Over-the-counter medication use among US preschool age children. JAMA. 1994;272:10251030.[Abstract]
27. McLennan J, Kotelchuck M. Parental prevention practices for young children in the context of maternal depression. Pediatrics. 2000;105:10901095.
28. Haas JS, McCormick MC. Hospital use and health status of women during the 5 years following the birth of a premature, low-birthweight infant. Am J Public Health. 1997;87:11511155.
29. Weissman MM, Sholomskas D, Pottenger M, Prusoff B, Locke B. Assessing depressive symptoms in five psychiatric populations: a validation study. Am J Epidemiol. 1977;106:203214.
30. Greenberg R, Haley N, Etzel R, Loda R. Measuring the exposure of infants to tobacco smoke: nicotine and cotinine in urine and saliva. N Engl J Med. 1984;310:10751078.[Abstract]
31. Rothman KJ. Modern Epidemiology. Boston, Mass: Little, Brown, & Co; 1986.
32. Kemper KJ. Family psychosocial screening: should we focus on high-risk settings? J Dev Behav Pediatr. 1994;15:336341.[Medline]
33. Kahn R, Wise P, Finkelstein J, Bernstein H, Lowe J, Homer C. The scope of unmet maternal health needs in pediatric settings. Pediatrics. 1999;103:576581.
34. NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. Chronicity of maternal depressive symptoms, maternal sensitivity, and child functioning at 36 months. Dev Psychol. 1999;35:12971310.[Medline]
35. Braveman P, Egerter S, Marchi K. The prevalence of low income among childbearing women in California: implications for the private and public sectors. Am J Public Health. 1999;89:868874.
36. Link BG, Phelan J. Social conditions as fundamental causes of disease. J Health Soc Behav. 1995;Spec No:8094.
37. Lynch JW, Kaplan GA, Salonen JT. Why do poor people behave poorly? Variation in adult health behaviours and psychosocial characteristics by stages of the socioeconomic lifecourse. Soc Sci Med. 1997;44:809819.
38. Felitti VJ, Anda RF, Nordenberg D, et al. The relationship of selected health risk behaviors, health status, and disease in adulthood to childhood abuse and household dysfunction: the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) study. Am J Prev Med. 1998;14:245258.[Medline]
39. Doescher MP, Franks P. Family care in the United States: a national profile. Med Care. 1997;35:564573.[Medline]
40. Guyer J, Mann C. Employed but Not Insured: A State-by-State Analysis of the Number of Low-Income Working Parents Who Lack Health Insurance. Washington, DC: Center on Budget and Policy Priorities; 1999.
41. Hanson KL. Is insurance for children enough? The link between parents and childrens health care use revisited. Inquiry. 1998;35:294302.[Medline]
42. McCormick MC, McCarton C, Brooks-Gunn J, Belt P, Gross RT. The Infant Health and Development Program: interim summary. J Dev Behav Pediatr. 1998;19:359370.[Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
H. Hiscock, J. Bayer, L. Gold, A. Hampton, O. C Ukoumunne, and M. Wake Improving infant sleep and maternal mental health: a cluster randomised trial Arch. Dis. Child., November 1, 2007; 92(11): 952 - 958. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. C. Whitaker, S. M. Phillips, and S. M. Orzol Food Insecurity and the Risks of Depression and Anxiety in Mothers and Behavior Problems in their Preschool-Aged Children Pediatrics, September 1, 2006; 118(3): e859 - e868. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. C. Whitaker, S. M. Orzol, and R. S. Kahn Maternal Mental Health, Substance Use, and Domestic Violence in the Year After Delivery and Subsequent Behavior Problems in Children at Age 3 Years. Arch Gen Psychiatry, May 1, 2006; 63(5): 551 - 560. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L.-C. Lee, C. T Halpern, I. Hertz-Picciotto, S. L Martin, and C. M Suchindran Child care and social support modify the association between maternal depressive symptoms and early childhood behaviour problems: a US national study. J. Epidemiol. Community Health, April 1, 2006; 60(4): 305 - 310. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. S. Minkovitz, D. Strobino, D. Scharfstein, W. Hou, T. Miller, K. B. Mistry, and K. Swartz Maternal Depressive Symptoms and Children's Receipt of Health Care in the First 3 Years of Life Pediatrics, February 1, 2005; 115(2): 306 - 314. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. S. Kahn, D. Brandt, and R. C. Whitaker Combined Effect of Mothers' and Fathers' Mental Health Symptoms on Children's Behavioral and Emotional Well-being Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med, August 1, 2004; 158(8): 721 - 729. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. L. Burdette, R. C. Whitaker, R. S. Kahn, and J. Harvey-Berino Association of Maternal Obesity and Depressive Symptoms With Television-Viewing Time in Low-Income Preschool Children Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med, September 1, 2003; 157(9): 894 - 899. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. E. Mansour, U. Kotagal, B. Rose, M. Ho, D. Brewer, A. Roy-Chaudhury, R. W. Hornung, T. J. Wade, and T. G. DeWitt Health-Related Quality of Life in Urban Elementary Schoolchildren Pediatrics, June 1, 2003; 111(6): 1372 - 1381. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |